This is what AI Radar shows you every week. A sample account: Fernway Coffee (a fictional brand), 14 weeks of scans across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, Gemini and Google AI.
Proof page: what the engine said, who it cited, and the week-by-week record for this one answer.
The answer did not name reddit.com in a sentence we can quote. It linked to it as a source.
Gemini left Fernway Coffee out in 3 of 3 runs this week and pointed at a community thread instead. Engines treat a real answer from a real person as evidence. A page on your own site rarely displaces it; a good answer in the same thread can.
Gemini grounds on Google search, so the same rules as Google AI apply. Its citations cannot be traced to a page, which is why this case has a domain but no link.
| Week | Linked you | First link |
|---|---|---|
| 27 Sept | 0 of 3 runs | reddit.com/ |
| 4 Oct | 0 of 3 runs | reddit.com/ |
| 11 Oct | 0 of 3 runs | reddit.com/ |
| 18 Oct | 0 of 3 runs | reddit.com/ |
| 25 Oct | 0 of 3 runs | reddit.com/ |
| 1 Nov | 0 of 3 runs | reddit.com/ |
| 8 Nov | 0 of 3 runs | reddit.com/ |
| 15 Nov | 0 of 3 runs | reddit.com/ |
Everything quoted is what the AI tool returned in the scan. The fix is Radar's read of what usually wins this kind of answer, not a claim about why the AI tool picked that page. Won is decided only by the weekly scan.